On Harper Row…

I think, more and more, my refrain for DC is becoming “I don’t think this will work the way you want it.”

Let me say that I don’t mind Harper as a character. I actually think she’s sort of interesting, and I love her interactions with her brother.  There are not enough “big sisters” in comics in general.  That humanizes her when she’s clearly being built up to be someone in the batfam, and as such, she’s being sort of… de-flawed. (She’ll have flaws later, I’m sure, but the writers are clearly trying to show her in her best light so fans will fall in love with her.)

That being said, the way they’re working Harper in? No.

They’re essentially working Harper in much like they did with Tim Drake.  The situation is different (Harper doesn’t care who Batman is; Tim knew for a long, long time. Tim is from an upper middle class family; Harper isn’t.), but the way it reads on paper feels very much the same.  Harper and Tim both recognized that Batman was in a tailspin. They both wanted to help Batman. 

Their solutions are quite different, but Tim and Harper are already dangerously similar in the grand scheme of ability that they are going to be constantly compared. They’re both hella smart, and they’re both not as physically capable as Dick, Damian, and Jason. It’s obvious that they aren’t the same character and that their areas of knowledge/intelligence are different. Tim is clearly the better detective, while Harper made blue prints good enough for Wayne Enterprise to use. 

But they’re similar ENOUGH. It almost reads like “So, last time we killed Robin, we introduced this kid who wanted to help Batman out! You guys loved him, here’s another one for the new millennium!” 

What makes this more frustrating is that I can’t help but think this backlash is going to be blamed on the fact that Harper is female, and I don’t think that’s the case at all. 

I think it’s more that this is the same scenario as last time, but there’s less breathing room and Harper is going to be taking the name from a beloved Robin while Tim was inheriting it from a Robin no one liked very much.

It’s poor story-telling, and it would be poor storytelling if Cullen was the clear next choice.  

While I think Harper can be interesting, it seems like it will only be a detriment to her character in the long run. 

34 notes

  1. scintillant-h reblogged this from locketofyourhair
  2. zatanass reblogged this from locketofyourhair
  3. tuticherry reblogged this from locketofyourhair
  4. chaseha-wing reblogged this from daggerpen
  5. locketofyourhair reblogged this from saphire-dance and added:
    I never said he was completely disliked, just like I never said Damian was completely beloved. In this medium, there is...
  6. theandysar reblogged this from luanna255 and added:
    It’s not about the background or how she is similar to Tim because she is incredibly smart and not as physical as the...
  7. saphire-dance reblogged this from locketofyourhair and added:
    I’m glad your Uncle got to call. My sister and I weren’t allowed to. We were 10 and 11 at the time, and my mother...
  8. queenxbubblegum reblogged this from locketofyourhair
  9. luanna255 reblogged this from daggerpen and added:
    Also, I don’t really think she’s so amazingly like Tim Drake? Okay, she’s smart and she admires Batman. Babs was also...
  10. daggerpen reblogged this from locketofyourhair
  11. anaspiringlibrarian reblogged this from protagonistically
  12. tommy-shepherd reblogged this from protagonistically
  13. protagonistically reblogged this from locketofyourhair and added:
    Yes.